| |
Brimstone and Treacle
|
|
| Year: |
1982
|
|
Director: |
Richard Loncraine
|
| Stars: |
Sting, Denholm Elliott, Joan Plowright, Suzanna Hamilton, Mary MacLeod, Benjamin Whitrow, Dudley Sutton
|
| Genre: |
Drama, Weirdo |
| Rating: |
  7 (from 2 votes) |
| Review: |
A middle-aged couple, Mr and Mrs Bates (Denholm Elliott and Joan Plowright), take care of their near-catatonic daughter (Suzanna Hamilton) at their home. Then Mr Bates bumps into a mysterious stranger (Sting) who, claiming to be a friend of his daughter, follows him home and offers to help out.
Writer Dennis Potter's unsettling religious drama was originally a television play produced in 1976. However, it was deemed unsuitable for broadcasting (i.e. banned until 1987, five years after this version was released), and so, in the manner of Alan Clarke's Scum, it was adapted into a slightly altered, but not improved, film.
Mr Bates is wracked with self-loathing, having partly caused the accident that sent his daughter into her severely disabled state, while Mrs Bates remains optimistic that a miracle will occur and she will recover. Enter creepy Sting (apparently doing some kind of Malcolm McDowell impersonation) who may be an angel or may be a devil (his character is more obviously demonic in the television play).
The first time we see Sting, he's emerging from a church amidst a crowd of choirboys. But he is full of contradictions: he steals from, yet offers to help the couple; one minute he's feeling the helpless daughter's tits, next minute he's a picture of piety, leading Mrs Bates in prayer. There may be a supernatural angle to him as well.
The film has a strange attitude to sex - here it's the cause of endless guilt and shame, but the worst kind of sex leads, perversely, to a happy ending of sorts. The most Dennis Potter-y moment is the bit where Mr Bates asks his secretary to raise her skirts, then calls her a "jezebel".
Although there is a certain unpleasant humour to the whole thing, Brimstone and Treacle is like a twisted parable, the message of which seems to be "God must be cruel to be kind", or even "God is sick". He certainly moves in mysterious ways, if this film is anything to go by. Music by Michael Nyman.
|
| Reviewer: |
Graeme Clark
|
| |
|
| Richard Loncraine (1946 - )
Capable British director who moves between film and television. Slade movie Flame was his first credit, then horror Full Circle and Dennis Potter adaptation Brimstone and Treacle were next. Michael Palin comedy The Missionary and the superb version of Shakespeare's Richard III were well received, as was his TV drama about Winston Churchill, The Gathering Storm. He then had a hit with romantic Britcom Wimbledon. |
|
|
Display comments